By Marilyn Jozwik
The Christmas season is like a stocking overflowing with treats of entertainment. But like moths to light, folks seem to gravitate to those familiar feel-good stories with universally positive messages.
And there’s none more positive than the power of believing on display in the time-honored “Miracle on 34th Street.” In fact, the 1947 film, starring Maureen O’Hara, John Payne, Natalie Wood and Edmund Gwenn, has been selected for preservation in the United States National Film Registry by the Library of Congress as being "culturally, historically or aesthetically significant.”
Forte Theatre Company has brought back the first show they produced in December of 2019, “Miracle on 34th Street: A Live Musical Radio Play.” The show is adapted from the 1947 radio broadcast by Lance Arthur Smith. This version adds some jazzy original music and unique arrangements of old favorites by Jon Lorenz. And of course, the beloved story of the department store Santa who thinks he’s the real deal and a little girl’s conversion to believing never grows old. Randall Dodge directs.
Molly Kempfer, from left, Michael Trimboli, Lydia Rose Eiche and Sean Lambie are lively, animated characters as they sing “Toy Department” in a scene from Forte Theatre Company’s “Miracle on 34th Street: A Live Musical Radio Play.” Liam Ledford, the sound designer, and Alexus Coleman, as Susan Walker, are in the background.
In this version, the audience plays the studio audience of 1947, complete with “On Air” and “Applause” signs. The performers in the live radio show play the parts of well-known actors and actresses, who introduce themselves before the show begins. It is a show within a show.
Forte’s show at Martin Luther Performing Arts Center is in an intimate space that nicely mimics a radio studio, offering the audience an opportunity to experience what live radio was like. Performers use scripts as they would have done for the radio play, although in this show they were virtually unused in Act 2.
The announcer of the radio show, played by Alex Chilsen, also is the narrator and accompanies vocalists on the piano. Chilsen also serves as the show’s music director and plays a number of small roles. He has the perfect radio voice and handles his many duties wonderfully.
Robert Zimmerman is Kris Kringle, who is at the center of the story. His insistence that he is Santa Claus leads to a dramatic, and sometimes humorous, courtroom scene. The outcome will determine whether the kindly oldster should be spending his days in an institution or continue to spread his message of hope. Zimmerman has the right look and demeanor to make even the audience believe.
The quartet of Molly Kempfer, Sean Lambie, Lydia Eiche Rose and Michael Trimboli puts the spice in this wassail for some delicious harmonies and solos. All four have multiple roles and handle the original tunes and creative versions of old favorites with flare.
The announcer (Alex Chilsen) accompanies the radio performers in a scene from Forte Theatre Company’s “Miracle on 34th Street: A Live Musical Radio Play.”
The clever “King Wenceslas” trio of tunes, that goes from jazzy to mellow, is especially appealing. Kempfer beautifully handles all the unexpected pacing and pausing in “Jazzy Halls” and “Melancholy Halls,” giving the old favorite a fresh sound.
As Doris Walker, Kempfer’s character evolves from the practical mom who has no use for fairy tales or make-believe, to one of Kringle’s converts. She is nicely paired with Lambie, who handles the role of Fred Gaily, Doris’s neighbor and love interest. I loved his twitchy Mr. Sawyer, Macy’s psychologist who deems Kris Kringle unfit, and his Irish priest with his thick brogue. Trimboli is another one of the cast’s Swiss Army knives, effectively handling roles of a number of characters including the DA, Thomas Mara.
Eiche and Kempfer are real crowd-pleasers with their hilarious portrayals of children. Eiche also belts out the tunes with relish and audience engagement, always adding something special to her roles.
Alexus Coleman is the star atop the tree with her role as Susan Walker, Doris’s daughter, who is skeptical of the existence of Santa. She nicely delivers in song her letter to Santa.
Ledford does a marvelous job adding layers of sound such as doors opening and closing, footsteps and dishes being cleared to enhance the show.
Forte’s show is filled with everything you need to make the holiday merry – a story of hope, sparkling performances, wonderful tunes and a sprinkling of snowflakes covering the stage at the end.
If you go:
Who: Forte Theatre Company
What: “Miracle on 34th Street: A Live Musical Radio Play”
When: Through Dec. 21
Where: Martin Luther Performing Arts Center, 5201 S. 76th St., Greendale
Info/Tickets: fortetheatrecompany.com/414-366-3634