By Marilyn Jozwik
“Sleuth” is a mystery lover’s mystery. Its two characters play mind games that at times seem absurd, at times dangerous, but always compelling. They match wits and mental acuity in their games, like skilled athletes do in theirs.
This show requires two talented, veteran performers and Sunset has found them for its presentation of “Sleuth.” Robin Christiansen plays the young travel agent, Milo Tindle, while Michael Pocaro is the long-time writer of popular murder mysteries, Andrew Wyke. Carol Dolphin, who always has her finger on the pulse of a good murder mystery, directs.
The show, by Anthony Shaffer, opened on Broadway in 1970 and was made into a movie three times. The 1972 version starred Laurence Olivier as Wyke and Michael Caine as Tindle, while, in the 2007 production, Caine played Wyke and Jude Law played Tindle.
The show takes place in the well-appointed home of Andrew Wyke. Of course, it is secluded in the English countryside, where the only passers-by may include the occasional “sheep rapist,” as Wyke says.
Wyke has invited Tindle to his home -- outfitted with games and curiosities -- for a particular purpose: to discuss Tindle’s affair with Wyke’s wife. But rather than confronting him angrily, Wyke seems more than happy to unload his young wife and her spendthrift ways. Although Wyke admits he can’t see what his wife sees in Tindle, he is anxious to part ways. But first, he wants to make sure that Tindle has enough money to accommodate her lifestyle. So, he devises a plan to have Tindle steal some valuable jewels from the safe. The plan is elaborate and conceived down to the last detail.
The first act has a dramatic ending, which leads to twists and turns in Act II and a fitting finale to the deadly game.
These performances are masterful. Pocaro wears his silky smoking jacket like the lord of the manor he is. Pocaro, who has directed countless comedies, says in his program bio that he’s wanted to play this role since the 1980s. And it shows. It seems like he’s been rehearsing the role his whole life. His Wyke dials through so many emotions -- his arrogance at the deceit and expertise in the games he’s devised (at one point calling himself “an Olympic sexual athlete”), his amusement at Tindle’s gullibility and his desperation when he sees he’s met his match. Just mesmerizing!
Christiansen beautifully handles the push and pull of his Tindle character and Pocaro’s Wyke. His Tindle is brash and greedy and becomes more than willing to compete in Wyke’s game even on Wyke’s “home court.”
While the show is thick with Shaffer’s clever dialogue, it never gets bogged down, thanks to the plot’s movement and the action and physicality of the characters that includes prat-falls, fights, crashing projectiles, gun play, ransacked rooms, a blown-up safe, broken windows and a set filled with interest. A ticking clock adds tension to one scene. Visits from inspectors add texture, as does Wyke’s acting out scenes as if they were part of one of his novels.
So, if you love a good murder mystery, you’ll certainly find a lot to love in Sunset’s “Sleuth.”
If you go:
Who: Sunset Playhouse
What: “Sleuth”
When: Through June 21
Where: 700 Wall St., Elm Grove
Info/Tickets: 262-782-4430/SunsetPlayhouse.com